The 33-year-old, who has earned over 60 caps for the Three Lions and previously captained the side under Gareth Southgate, had been recalled by Tuchel for March’s international friendlies but ultimately failed to convince the German coach of his place in the final 26-man party heading to North America. England’s squad for the tournament, co-hosted by the USA, Canada, and Mexico, is set to be formally unveiled on Friday.
Tuchel’s decision marks a significant shift from the Southgate era, during which Maguire was a regular despite fluctuating club form. Reports indicate the new manager has preferred alternatives such as Marc Guéhi, John Stones, Ezri Konsa, Dan Burn, and Jarell Quansah in central defence. The omission comes alongside other notable absences, including Phil Foden and Cole Palmer, while Ivan Toney has earned a surprise recall following a prolific season.
Reacting to Maguire’s public statement, Tuchel admitted he was taken aback. “I was a bit surprised [by his reaction], but I respect his personality a lot. I respect his quality a lot,” the England manager said. He acknowledged the defender’s frustration while standing by his selections aimed at squad balance and recent form.
Maguire’s family has also voiced strong feelings. His mother reportedly expressed being “disgusted” by the snub, while broader reactions from former players like Wayne Rooney have described the defender as “very unlucky” to miss out.
The news has sparked intense debate among fans and pundits, with many questioning whether experience and leadership qualities were undervalued in favour of younger or in-form options ahead of a major tournament where set-pieces could prove decisive. Maguire’s last major tournament appearance came at the 2022 World Cup in Qatar.
